Multilevel governance and organizational performance: Investigating the political‐bureaucratic labyrinth

Abstract

Research on governance has extensively explored the complex interactions of governmental, nongovernmental, and for-profit entities in the execution of public policy. It has consistently failed, however, to model empirically the joint effects of political and bureaucratic actors in governance systems. To address this issue, a theory of multilevel governance built upon the foundation of representative bureaucracy was developed and tested. Results from an analysis of Texas school districts suggest that Latinos at all levels of the governance system, political and managerial, influence representation at other levels. Findings also indicate that Latinos at each level of governance have positive effects, directly and indirectly, on outcomes for Latino students. The influence of both political and managerial actors at times extends beyond the immediately adjoining level; the effects of such actors cascade through the governance system. The results show that a priority for systematic research should be the identification of approaches and settings for examining the multilevel aspect of governance. © 2004 by the Association for Public Policy Analysis and Management.

Public management reform and organizational performance: An empirical assessment of the U.K. Labour government's public service improvement strategy

“…Most empirical work, however, examines only one of the relevant dimensions; for example, governance structures (Knott & Payne, 2004), representation of minority groups in the bureaucracy (Meier, O'Toole, & Nicholson-Crotty, 2004) networks (Ewalt, 2004), contracting (Heinrich & Fournier, 2004), and job specialization (Hill, 2004). These studies provide important insights on the impact of each of these variables.…”

Contracting for management: Assessing management capacity under alternative service delivery arrangements

“…Though a notoriously complex and difficult topic of study, effective management improves government service delivery (Hill & Lynn, 2004;Hou, Moynihan, & Ingraham, 2003;Knott & Payne, 2004;Meier, O'Toole, & Nicholson-Crotty, 2004; for a review, see Boyne, 2003). The public management literature identifies a range of managerial tasks and functions necessary for successful service delivery, including: planning and strategizing; decision-making; budgeting and mobilizing financial resources; managing human resources (e.g., motivating, communicating, negotiating, bargaining); evaluating and tracking service quality (e.g., identifying perform-ance measures, monitoring); and managing across organizational boundaries (Perry, 1996;Rainey, 1991;Starling, 1998;Stillman, 1996).…”

Governance, Health Policy Implementation and the Added Value of Regionalization

“…Most recent research (e.g., O'Toole 2000; Meier et al 2004) devoted to public policy analysis places greater emphasis on the question of governance, understood in the broadest sense as the organization of collective action (Prakash and Hart 1999). Governance is concerned more with strategic issues than with management.…”