Multilevel Zero-inflated Censored Beta Regression Modeling for Proportions and Rate Data with Extra-zeros

Abstract

Objectives Zero-inflated proportion or rate data nested in clusters due to the sampling structure can be found in many disciplines. Sometimes, the rate response may not be observed for some study units because of some limitations (false negative) like failure in recording data and the zeros are observed instead of the actual value of the rate/proportions (low incidence). In this study, we proposed a multilevel zero-inflated censored Beta regression model that can address zero-inflation rate data with low incidence.Methods We assumed that the random effects are independent and normally distributed. The performance of the proposed approach was evaluated by application on a three level real data set and a simulation study. We applied the proposed model to analyze brucellosis diagnosis rate data and investigate the effects of climatic and geographical position. For comparison, we also applied the standard zero-inflated censored Beta regression model that does not account for correlation.Results Results showed the proposed model performed better than zero-inflated censored Beta based on AIC criterion. Height (p-value <0.0001), temperature (p-value <0.0001) and precipitation (p-value = 0.0006) significantly affected brucellosis rates. While, precipitation in ZICBETA model was not statistically significant (p-value =0.385). Simulation study also showed that the estimations obtained by maximum likelihood approach had reasonable in terms of mean square error.Conclusions The results showed that the proposed method can capture the correlations in the real data set and yields accurate parameter estimates.