Multiple primary malignant neoplasms (MPMNs) or multiple primary malignancies are defined as two or more histologically distinct malignancies present in the same individual. While second or higher-order malignancies account for approximately 18% of all cancers in the United States, it is reasonable to presume that MPMNs are now occurring more frequently than previously reported. Underserved groups such as blacks and Hispanics may represent a high proportion of these underreported cases due to well-established health disparities. Although the role of health disparities has been well established in single primary malignancies, less is known on racial differences in patients with multiple primaries. In comparing MPMNs by race, blacks have lower survival rates compared to white patients. Moreover, despite the lower overall incidence of MPMNs in blacks compared to white patients, when broken down by the specific types of cancers and gender, there are significant racial disparities in the incidence of prostate cancer and possibly other cancers. Further research and case reports are required to explore the risk factors of developing MPMNs in these groups. Our case series explores three African American patients with MPMNs that are rarely described in the literature and outlines the management challenges of treating multiple malignancies.