A pair of chiral bis(amidine) [BAM] proton complexes provide reagent (catalyst)-controlled, highly diastereoand enantioselective direct aza-Henry reactions leading to α-alkylsubstituted α,β-diamino esters. A C 2 -symmetric ligand provides high anti-selectivity, while a nonsymmetric congener exhibits synselectivity in this example of diastereodivergent, enantioselective catalysis. A detailed computational analysis is reported for the first time, one that supports distinct models for selectivity resulting from the more hindered binding cavity of the C 1 -symmetric ligand. Binding in this congested pocket accommodates four hydrogen bond contacts among ligands and substrates, ultimately favoring a pre-syn arrangement highlighted by pyridinium-azomethine activation and quinolinium-nitronate activation. The complementary transition states reveal a wide range of alternatives. Comparing the C 1 -and C 2 -symmetric catalysts highlights distinct electrophile binding orientations despite their common hydrogen bond donor−acceptor features. Among the factors driving unusual high syndiastereoselection are favorable dispersion forces that leverage the anthracenyl substituent of the C 1 -symmetric ligand.