<b><i>Introduction:</i></b> Onychomycosis is a complex nail disease that is commonly seen in daily practice. <b><i>Methods:</i></b> Electronic health records of clinically diagnosed onychomycosis patients were extracted using DataDerm – a dermatology data registry hosted by the American Academy of Dermatology – spanning from the year 2016 to 2022. <b><i>Results:</i></b> Regardless of age, an increasing trend in patient volume was observed in the Southern US region, which accounted for 50.7–56.9% of onychomycosis patients in 2022. A coinfection of tinea pedis was present among 15.6–22.5% of patients. Diagnostic testing was infrequently utilized with less than one-quarter of patients having a histopathologic examination (12.7–21.9%) followed by fungal culture (5.5–8.2%) and direct microscopic examination (3.3–6.0%). Treatments were infrequently prescribed, accounting for less than one-quarter of patients (orals, terbinafine: 20.8–29.1%, fluconazole: 12.9–16.5%; topicals, efinaconazole: 3.2–13.8%); over 30% of treated patients received a combination regimen or experienced switching of treatments. Prescribing patterns did not significantly differ in vulnerable patient groups such as elderly patients and in patients with concomitant tinea pedis. Patients receiving a topical and/or oral antifungal prescription were frequently not tested to confirm the onychomycosis diagnosis (76.9%). <b><i>Conclusion:</i></b> Our findings add to a growing body of literature calling for the improvement of onychomycosis management practices.