Silicon, having an indirect optical transition, results in optoelectronic devices with very low efficiency. Although porous silicon shows PL, thought to be primarily due to quantum confinement, and superlattice structures have demonstrated stable photoluminescence, PL and electroluminescence, EL, it is argued that the common denominator may be due to oxygen complexes, rather than quantum size effects. All schemes employing quantum confinement to break the momentum conservation require annealing for reasonable efficiency. The Si -SiO 2 superlattices do not represent the answer to the search of optical activities in silicon based materials; rather, provide the basis for the type of structures in searching for the proper Si-based superlattices. The main stumbling block seems to be the usual defects induced by high local strain, leading to nonradiative channels. Thus breakthrough is still waiting to be discovered.