Narratives of Masculinity in the Daily Sun: Implications for HIV Risk and Prevention

Abstract

Dominant and hegemonic masculinities typically place women and men at risk of contracting HIV through reinforcing gender inequalities. Challenging these masculinities is increasingly seen as a precondition fortackling HIV&AIDS. Narratives of masculinity are the symbolic tools, which men draw upon to construct their social identities. Understanding the composition of these narratives of masculinity is central for understanding how narratives of masculinity may, or may not, shape HIV-related health behaviours. The media is a central space in which narratives of masculinity are produced and reproduced. We analyse five days' worth of the newspaper, the Daily Sun, in December 2008 to identify the different narratives of masculinity that circulate in the newspaper. Through thematic analysis we identify three different global-narratives: (i) Masculinity and work, (ii) Masculinity, violence and crime, and (iii) Masculinity and HIV. We explore each of these narratives and suggest how they may create contexts in which certain HIV-related health behaviours are more or less likely. We suggest that despite the variation in the narratives of masculinity circulating in the Dai/y Sun these narratives are limited and typically undermine HIV-related health behaviours by either sustaining a masculine ideal that is unachievable, emphasising a narrative of a disempowered masculinity, or by providing limited masculine narratives around HIV&AIDS. We emphasise how this undermines HIV prevention and suggest possible approaches to challenging these narratives.

HIV- and AIDS-associated neurocognitive functioning in Zambia – a perspective based on differences between the genders

“… 39 This trend has been linked to cultural and social issues to do with masculinity and power that demand physical and emotional strength from the male population, thus making them less likely to seek treatment early as a way of avoiding feelings of vulnerability and loss of power. 40 …”

Gendered constructions of the impact of HIV and AIDS in the context of the HIV‐positive seroconcordant heterosexual relationship

“…Both female participants quoted above evidenced hurt and pain associated with betrayal and both did so with a sense of powerlessness and desperation that relegated them to the victim/spectator position [20]. This sense of helplessness associated with the victim role is as much a mirror to the gendered power differentials at play in men and women's negotiation of disclosure and betrayal, as it is a reflection of the co-option of women in reinforcing gendered constructions of victimology [5], which are predictive of negative relational and health outcomes for both partners [29,30].…”

Dialogues Through Autophotography: Young Masculinity And HIV Identity in Kwazulu-Natal

“…This research has had varying focuses including young masculinity and disability (Joseph & Lindegger, 2007), violent behaviour and peaceful alternatives (Hamlall, 2013), peer group counsellors (Davies & Eagle, 2007), group constructions and homophobia (Blackbeard & Lindegger, 2007), ideal masculinity (Lindegger & Maxwell, 2007) and the acceptance or rejection of peer-validated masculinities (Langa, 2010). The relevance of such research included gender-responsive education, health risk and prevention, health services provision and programmes to address gender violence and interpersonal violence (Gibbs & Jobson, 2011;Hamlall, 2013;Morrell et al, 2012).…”