Alternariol (AOH) and alternariol monomethyl ether (AME) are two main Alternaria mycotoxins that endanger human health. In this study, a single-chain antibody fragment (scFv) capable of equivalently and specifically recognizing AOH and AME was first expressed, and its equivalent recognition mechanism was discussed. According to molecular docking and dynamic simulation, the C9 site, which was always exposed outside the binding cavity, made the structural differences between AOH and AME negligible. Due to the high similarity of structures, AOH and AME interacted with almost the same amino acids on the scFv; thus, the same interaction mode and interaction force were produced. This was considered to be the most critical reason for the equivalent recognition. Thus, the exposure of common structures was considered a potential strategy to obtain the equivalent recognition antibodies, and C9 was considered the key site in the process of hapten modification. These results laid a theoretical foundation for further research on antibodies against Alternaria mycotoxins. It could promote the rapid detection of AOH and AME in food and provide a new idea for targeted preparation of antibodies that could recognize multiple hazards with similar structures.