This paper is concerned with the problem of designing satisfactory loworder (incomplete state feedback) controllers starting with a high-order, state-space model. Two design approaches are considered: the control law reduction technique, recently developed by the authors (Wilson et al., 19731, and the well-known model reduction approach. These two design techniques are used to develop a variety of low-order controllers for a double-effect evaporator starting with a 10th-order model. Experimental and simulated response data from the computer-controlled evaporator demonstrate the superiority of the control law reduction approach in this application. It is also shown that several of the previously published modal approaches to model reduction are basically equivalent since they yield identical reduced-order models.
ROBERT
SCOPEIn many practical applications of modern control theory the most difficult problem is to obtain a suitable process model. An analytical approach using basic chemical engineering principles often results in a dynamic model which consists of a large number of nonlinear differential equations. The model is usually too complicated for use in controller design or for implementation as part of the actual control system. Consequently, for purposes of control system design it is common practice to linearize the model and assume time-invariant behavior. Fortunately, the resulting linear "state-space model" (that is, a set of firstorder differential equations) will usually adequately describe the process transients in the region of normal operation and provide a suitable basis for control system design. However, many of the multivariable control design techniques (Gould, 1969) result in a control law that requires the availability of all elements of the state vector. Such control laws are frequently impractical because of their complexity and because in many applications it is not practical to measure or estimate all of the state variables. Hence there has been widespread interest in developing control laws that require only a subset of the state vector to be available. The resulting controllers are usually referred to as incomplete state feedback or low-order controllers.This investigation is concerned with the problem of designing a satisfactory low-order, multivariable controller starting with a high-order, state-space model of a process. To be judged satisfactory, the low-order controller should perform almost as well as more complicated high-order (state-feedback) controllers. Emphasis is placed on discrete process models and discrete controllers since they are more convenient than their continuous counterparts for on-line implementation via digital process computers. Two basic approaches were used to design loworder controllers:1. Model Reduction Approach. The original high-order model is simplified using a modal analysis to eliminate selected state variables, that is, to reduce the order of the model. The resulting low-order model then serves as a basis for designing a low-order controller usin...