Pancreatic cancer, with its increasing incidence and lowest 5-year survival rate, is predicted to become the second leading cause of cancer deaths by 2030. Current clinical trials have shown limited improvement, highlighting the need for new therapies. The sigma-2 receptor (S2R), with roles in tumor progression, is a target for novel thiosemicarbazones (TSCs). FA4 has shown potent activity against pancreatic cancer in vivo. We synthesized complexes of FA4 with Cu(II) and Pt(II), and compared their efficacy with complexes of the non-S2R-targeting TSC 1. TSC-Cu exhibited over 50-fold higher in vitro cytotoxicity than TSCs-Pt, which was less active than TSCs. FA4-Cu induced apoptotic cell death via ER and mitochondrial stress showing more potent activity than FA4. This in vitro effect was replicated in the preclinical PANC-1 model, where FA4-Cu was more potent than FA4, 1, and 1-Cu. These results support further exploration of FA4-Cu as a potential therapy for pancreatic cancer.