Neither Corporate, Nor Family: The Indian “Patronal” Farm

Abstract

After the disappearance of socialist State farms and cooperatives, the diversity of farms in the world seemed to have been reduced to a simple dichotomy: family farms on the one hand and corporate farming on the other. The former category, the dominant model on the planet, includes undertakings where labor is provided by the family, while corporate farming that was long limited to South America, is exclusively based on hired labor. This reading grid, however, turns out to be particularly problematic when looking at the Indian case. Despite their small size, a considerable number of Indian farms make use of a combination of family and hired labor. Based on an analysis of national statistics and fieldwork in 13 small regions, this article characterizes agricultural work and how family and hired labor function together on Indian farms. It shows that alongside family farms where wage labor (either hiring or being hired) serves to ensure full employment for family labor, there is another type of farm, which we define as “patronal farm”, where hiring agricultural laborers increases the income earned by family labor. In our surveys, this is systematically the case for irrigated agriculture, where wages paid to laborers are lower than the agricultural labor productivity per workday. After describing the characteristics of this original model, the article discusses its coherence with India's political economy and questions its sustainability.

Sustainable Development between Demonstration Farm and Agricultural Labor Productivity: Evidence from Family Farms in the Mountainous Area of Western China

“…For instance, mechanisms and tools of agricultural policy, agricultural mechanization, crop establishment, wage labor, quality capabilities of agricultural managers, level of internal management, rural financial credit system, satisfaction of social service demand, support for agricultural science and technology, and quality and safety of agricultural products, etc. [40][41][42][43][44][45][46]. As it should be, objectively speaking, the development of family farms in different countries and regions at different stages of development is affected by natural, social, economic, cultural, technical and other factors.…”

Le futur du travail en agriculture

“…D'une façon plus générale, elles peuvent, par leur cahier des charges, peser sur les conditions de travail dans le secteur de la production. Enfin, si l'agriculture familiale domine dans ces pays (Bosc et Sourisseau, 2019), cela n'exclut pas l'émergence de formes patronales, qui associent main-d'oeuvre familiale et salariat comme l'ont montré Aubron et al (2022) en Inde. La capacité à générer de l'emploi des méga-fermes, des grands projets d'investissement agricole (comme en Chine ou au Vietnam en élevage laitier ou porcin) est pour le moins controversé (Mercandalli et al, 2021).…”

Understanding Constraints and Enablers of Climate Risk Management Strategies: Evidence from Smallholder Dairy Farmers in Regional South India

“…Much of the feed to animals is derived from agricultural remains and by-products. Although dairy farming has been reported as an age-old and complementary agricultural practice, particularly for the marginal and landless farmers in India [4], it has gained much popularity and attracted attention of the large farming households in recent decades [5][6][7].…”