Famous 16th-century scientist and philosopher Frances Bacon noted how, at times, the remedy to a problem could be worse than the disease. We believe this speaks to the point by Verd et al. when they suggest that supplementing breastfed newborns with formula to avoid the "danger zone" of too much weight loss presents another danger of formula supplementation. Indeed, the interruption of breastfeeding by the introduction of formula can have serious and lifelong repercussions for both mother and infant. The decision to begin supplementation for breastfed newborns should not be taken lightly and, as noted by Verd and colleagues, should include more than just an evaluation of infant weight. The newborn's latch to the breast, milk transfer, outputs, and satiety after feedings, as well as weight checks, should all be part of a comprehensive feeding evaluation.In their letter to the editor, Verd et al. described how very few studies have collected breastfeeding outcomes beyond hospital discharge. They noted how our findings and those by Flaherman et al. ( 2017) "favor equal ability to breastfeed among mothers of infants irrespective of their birth weight loss." We were able to show that newborns gained weight at a similar pace, despite differences in early weight loss. These are critical preliminary findings that suggest that healthy term neonates have a greater capacity to cope and recover from weight loss than previously believed.It should also be noted that Flaherman et al. showed that exacerbated weight loss was strongly associated with decreased likelihood of exclusive breastfeeding. These findings collaborate with our own, which showed that on Day 14, the exclusive breastfeeding rate for newborns who lost > 7% of their birth weight was significantly less than for infants who lost ≤ 7%. These results support the belief that weight loss is a driving force behind formula supplementation. What must be stressed, however, is our lack of understanding regarding expected neonatal weight loss. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics (2012), weight loss for healthy breastfed newborns should be no more than 7%. Yet, in our two studies of more than 400 newborns, we were able to demonstrate that more than half of healthy term breastfed newborns lost more than the conventional 7% (DiTomasso & Paiva, 2017;Thulier, 2017). We therefore propose that inaccurate beliefs about neonatal weight changes for breastfed newborns may be contributing to lower breastfeeding rates in the United States.