Network of Games: An Ecology of Games Informing Integral and Inclusive City Developments

Abstract

This article analyzes possibilities for connecting individual city games for building a network of games working together. City gaming works along with the understanding that cities are self-organizing systems, influenced by multiple bottom-up and top-down actors with varying interests and powers. Affordable housing, climate adaptation, or area development are examples of urgent urban challenges city games typically focus on. The assumption is that if these specialized games could be linked, then a large game infrastructure built as a modular system, can offer various game combinations responding to urban challenges in an integral and holistic way. To test a working game network, city games, models, and digital apps have been linked through their shared datasets as well as game interfaces. Two city experiments have been conducted in two Dutch cities—Amsterdam and Breda—which enabled the testing to function as “constructive design research.” In Amsterdam (Klimaatspel) two separate city games were connected through their datasets, while in Breda (Play the Koepel) datasets and interfaces merged to create a new game. Used data models are the Energy Transition Model developed by Quintel and the urban plan cost simulator software of Urban Reality. Used game interfaces (digital and analog) include the Typeform, the Network of Games app, the Urban Reality simulator, and the Play the City table-top game format. The testing considered two different approaches for a potential game network. The first option assumes an all-encompassing digital app, reformatting and involving various games and models in a single interface. The second option is an open approach that looks to link custom-made games with existing interfaces. The second option allows both simultaneous and sequential linking. Two experiments utilizing sequential and simultaneous integration of diverse digital tools suggest that a collection of interfaces connecting to each other throughout the entire process from a digital poll to an app, a simulator or a webinar, or analog game sessions is more effective than a single mobile phone app for all potential game interactions. Considering city games as an ecology of city tools that can be linked to one another becomes through this study a concrete goal to reach. Through combining specialized games, addressing complex city challenges becomes possible. This step enables a more effective participation environment for diverse experts and non-experts.

Modeling Urban Spaces with Cubes: Building analogue serious games for collaborative planning

“…The majority of these games are digital, although there are some examples of analogue games (Dodig & Groat, 2019;Tan, 2017), some even depart from MBGs inspirations (Mewborne & Mitchell, 2019;Sousa, 2020a). Although digital games allow deep and interactive simulations and can reach enormous quantities of users, analogue games have considerable advantages for spatial and urban planning.…”

“…Serious games are a growing trend among urban planners (Dodig & Groat, 2019;Sousa et al, 2022b;Tan, 2017). The literature highlights the advantages of using games to support spatial and urban planning processes, mostly as a teaching and public engagement tool.…”

Ostrakinda: A Game-Based Learning Toolkit for Ancient Mediterranean Cities

“…Additionally, the EU-funded Public Play Space (PPS) project , developed by a multidisciplinary consortium, cataloged 30 public space games focusing on environmental awareness, collective design, storytelling, learning, and decision-making (Farinea et al, 2021). Furthermore, the EU project titled 'Play the City' has incorporated 42 city games in 20 cities since 2010, utilizing community engagement as an integral problem-solving and collaborative decisionmaking tool (Tan, 2017). However, these popular games merely scratch the surface of the extensive body of literature encompassing a wide range of (un)published games.…”

The Future’s Not What It Used To Be: Urban Wormholes, Simulation, Participation, and Planning in the Metaverse

“…Tewdwr-Jones and Wilson (2022) discuss the use of LEGOs for the co-creation of innovative projects and Delaney (2022) presents an innovative use of Minecraft as a participatory support tool for urban design and planning projects. Tan (2022) discusses how a network of games can be created by connecting games to other available datasets and games. Raghothama et al (2022) highlight the impact choice of technology (analogue vs. digital) has on user experience in terms of learning, agency, and exploration.…”