Context: Anterior tibial shear force and knee valgus moment increase anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) loading. Muscle coactivation of the quadriceps and hamstrings influences anterior tibial shear force and knee valgus moment, thus potentially influencing ACL loading and injury risk. Therefore, identifying exercises that facilitate balanced activation of the quadriceps and hamstrings might be beneficial in ACL injury rehabilitation and prevention.Objective: To quantify and compare quadriceps with hamstrings coactivation electromyographic (EMG) ratios during commonly used closed kinetic chain exercises.Design: Cross-sectional study. Setting: Research laboratory.Patients or Other Participants: Twenty-seven healthy, physically active volunteers (12 men, 15 women; age ¼ 22.1 6 3.1 years, height ¼ 171.4 6 10 cm, mass ¼ 72.4 6 16.7 kg).Intervention(s): Participants completed 9 separate closed chain therapeutic exercises in a randomized order.Main Outcome Measure(s): Surface electromyography quantified the activity level of the vastus medialis (VM), vastus lateralis (VL), medial hamstrings (MH), and biceps femoris (BF) muscles. The quadriceps-to-hamstrings (Q:H) coactivation ratio was computed as the sum of average quadriceps (VM, VL) EMG amplitude divided by the sum of average hamstrings (MH, BF) EMG amplitude for each trial. We used repeated-measures analyses of variance to compare Q:H ratios and individual muscle contributions across exercises (a ¼ .05), then used post hoc Tukey analyses.Results: We observed a main effect for exercise (F 3,79 ¼ 22.6, P , .001). The post hoc Tukey analyses revealed smaller Q:H ratios during the single-limb dead lift (2.87 6 1.77) than the single-limb squat (5.52 6 2.89) exercise. The largest Q:H ratios were observed during the transverse-lunge (7.78 6 5.51, P , .001), lateral-lunge (9.30 6 5.53, P , .001), and forward-lunge (9.70 6 5.90, P , .001) exercises.Conclusions: The most balanced (smallest) coactivation ratios were observed during the single-limb dead-lift, lateral-hop, transverse-hop, and lateral band-walk exercises. These exercises potentially could facilitate balanced activation in ACL rehabilitation and injury-prevention programs. They also could be used in postinjury rehabilitation programs in a safe and progressive manner.Key Words: anterior cruciate ligament, closed kinetic chain exercises
Key PointsExercises that use a quadriceps-dominant activation might negatively affect the knee by increasing strain on the anterior cruciate ligament. The hamstrings muscles can counteract the deleterious effect of the quadriceps except when activation is minimal. The most balanced quadriceps-to-hamstrings coactivation ratios were produced during the single-limb dead-lift, lateral-hop, transverse-hop, and lateral band-walk exercises. Exercises with a more balanced quadriceps-to-hamstrings coactivation ratio may benefit anterior cruciate ligament rehabilitation and injury-prevention programs.