Many forms of neurodegeneration are ascribed to excessive cellular Ca 2~loading (Ca2~hypothesis). We examined quantitatively whether factors other than 1Ca 2l oading were determinants of excitotoxic neurode~'eneration. Cell survival, morphology, free intracellular Cas1 concentration ([Ca2~]), and 45Ca2~accumulation were measured in cultured cortical neurons loaded with known quantities of Ca2through distinct transmembrane pathways triggered by excitatory amino acids, cell membrane depolarization, or Ca2ĩonophores. Contrary to the Ca2h ypothesis, the relationships between Ca2~load and cell survival, free [Ca2~]~, and Ca2~-inducedmorphological alterations depended primarily on the route of Ca2~influx, not the Ca2~load. Notably, Ca2~loading via NMDA receptor channels was toxic, whereas identical Ca2~loads incurred through voltage-sensitive Ca2~channels were completely innocuous. Furthermore, accounting quantitatively for Ca2~loading via NMDA receptors uncovered a previously unreported component of L-glutamate neurotoxicity apparently not mediated by ionotropic or metabotropic glutamate receptors. lt was synergistic with toxicity attributable to glutamate-evoked Ca2~loading, and correlated with enhanced cellular ATP depletion. This previously unrecognized toxic action of glutamate constituted a chief excitotoxic mechanism under conditions producing submaximal Ca2~loading. We conclude that (a) Ca2~neurotoxicity is a function of the Ca2~infltlx pathway, not Ca2 load, and (b) glutamate toxicity may not be restricted to its actions on glutamate receptors.