Zirconium and hafnium
complexes bearing cycloheptane- or cyclononane-fused
[OSSO]-type bis(phenolato) ligands ([C7] and [C9], respectively) were
prepared and subjected to the polymerization of 1-hexene as the precatalyst.
The polymerizations produced poly(1-hexene)s with high activities
and high isospecificity, where complexes bearing [C9] were more reactive
than those bearing [C7]. Their activities were compared with those
of the corresponding complexes bearing cyclohexane- and cyclooctane-fused
ligands ([C6] and [C8], respectively), which we reported previously,
to show the order of activity [C8] > [C9] > [C7] > [C6].
The ring-size
effect on the activity was investigated with the help of DFT calculations
on active and dormant cationic zirconium species, π complexes
of the active species with propene, and transition states for propene
insertion into the Zr–C(iBu) bond. The order
of activity speculated from the activation energy, that is the energy
difference between the π complex and the corresponding transition
state, was [C8] > [C7] > [C9] ≈ [C6]. However, calculations
on active and dormant cationic zirconium complexes including [B(C6F5)4]− as the counteranion
revealed that the active species are more stable than the dormant
species by 9.1 kcal mol–1 for [C8] followed by 7.4
kcal mol–1 for [C9] and 3.1 kcal mol–1 for [C7] and, in contrast, that the active species with [C6] is
less stable by 1.0 kcal mol–1 than the corresponding
dormant species. Thus, the abundances of active species bearing [C6]
and [C7] are reduced, which leads to the reversal of the order of
[C7] and [C9] on the basis of activation energy to reproduce the order
observed experimentally.