Hybrid nanocomposites based on poly(3,6-dianiline-2,5-dichloro-1,4-benzoquinone) (PDACB) in salt form and graphene oxide (GO) have been obtained for the first time, and the significant influence of the preparation method on the composition and structure of nanocomposites and their functional properties has been demonstrated. Nanocomposites were prepared in three ways: via ultrasonic mixing of PDACB and GO; via in situ oxidative polymerization of 3,6-dianiline-2,5-dichloro-1,4-benzoquinone (DACB) in the presence of GO; and by heating a suspension of previously prepared PDACB and GO in DMF with the removal of the solvent. The results of the study of the composition, chemical structure, morphology, thermal stability and electrical properties of nanocomposites obtained via various methods are presented. Nanocomposites obtained by mixing the components in an ultrasonic field demonstrated strong intermolecular interactions between PDACB and GO both due to the formation of hydrogen bonds and π-stacking, as well as through electrostatic interactions. Under oxidative polymerization of DACB in the presence of GO, the latter participated in the oxidative process, being partially reduced. At the same time, a PDACB polymer film was formed on the surface of the GO. Prolonged heating for 4 h at 85 °C of a suspension of PDACB and GO in DMF led to the dedoping of PDACB with the transition of the polymer to the base non-conductive form and the reduction of GO. Regardless of the preparation method, all nanocomposites showed an increase in thermal stability compared to PDACB. All nanocomposites were characterized by a hopping mechanism of conductivity. Direct current (dc) conductivity σdc values varied within two orders of magnitude depending on the preparation conditions.