New evidence on fund performance in extreme events

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to compare the return performance and persistence of ethical and conventional mutual funds during two extreme events, the Asian and the global financial crises under Shariah constraints. Design/methodology/approach The overall sample comprises of 129 Islamic mutual funds (IMFs) and 350 conventional mutual funds (CMFs) in Malaysia, and the average monthly data cover two periods of market cycles, before and during a financial crisis. The net of all expenses data is obtained from the Morningstar Database. This study employs various market risk-adjusted performance measures (ratios) to estimate the funds’ overall performance during the crises, and then it uses CAPM model to estimate the parameters via panel data approach. Moreover, paper employs the two persistence performance measures on IMFs and CMFs through contingency tables. It tests for the performance persistence effects for IMFs, CMFs using repeat winner and the cross-product ratio (CPR) tests proposed by Malkiel (1995) and Brown and Goetzmann (1995), respectively. Findings The main findings of the paper are: on average, both funds IMF and the CMF outperform the market return during the entire sample period; none of the funds is better than the “others” during the financial crises and the pre-crisis periods; the ethical fund – IMF outperforms the CMF over the study period. This outcome also indicates that ethical funds are more persistent especially during and the pre-crisis AFC and the GFC periods. Research limitations/implications The finding of this study is limited to only Malaysian data because the objective was to guideline investors and market players in Malaysia to prefer investing in Islamic ethical funds to diversify their investment portfolio. Practical implications Cautions to use existing ratio measures and CAPM model rather persistence measures may be used with existing methodologies in light of extreme events which influenced investor decision making for better returns at lower risks. Social implications A class of ethical funds consists of religious sustainable, socially responsible and impact-investing (SRI) funds but Shariah implications of halal investment must be observed to avoid prohibited practices within the class of SRI funds. Originality/value The work done in this paper are original in the sense that the authors employed various ratios to measure fund performance in conjunction with CAPM model and then tested for two persistence performance measures; the repeat winner and CPR tests.

The Determinants of Credit Risk: An Evidence from ASEAN and GCC Islamic Banks

“…As discussed earlier that the aim of this paper is to examine the determinants of credit risk by examining a few bank specific variables and dummy variables. So, to this end we considered ten (10) explanatory variables and three (3) dummy variables representing countries group, age and financial crisis in a similar manner as Mansor et al (2019) did for the case of Islamic Mutual fund 11 . The results are tabulated in Table 3 which summarize the summary statistics regarding credit risk and bank-specific characteristic variables for all 40 banks.…”

“…Just recently,Mansor et al (2019) studied the return performance and persistence of Islamic and conventional mutual funds during financial crises periods in the presence of spurious regression and noted misleading and controversial conclusions on the performance of funds.…”

Corporate governance mechanism and the risk exposure of Islamic mutual funds: evidence from Islamic countries

“…Luo and Bhatti (2019) analyzed the co-movement and dependence structure of Islamic mutual funds using copula methods and showed that Islamic mutual funds have low dependence with various market indices. Mansor et al (2019) analyzed the performance of Islamic mutual funds along with analyzing the risk exposure of these funds. They showed that Islamic funds outperform market indices even in the crises period.…”

Focusing Project Financing for Growth and Realizing the Higher Objectives of Shar¯ı‘ah

“…It becomes the move for "Islamizing" any conventional products without any limitation-treasury bills, commercial paper, derivatives, shares of conventional banks, etc. IBFIs, particularly the Islamic Funds, had shown more resilience than conventional finance to the recent Global Financial Crisis (Mansor, Al Rahahleh, & Bhatti, 2019), but that could be because of the reason that their involvement in financial derivatives and other structured products was minimal by that time.…”