Aspirin loading (chewable or intravenous) as soon as possible after presentation is a class I recommendation by current ST elevation myocardial infarction (STEMI) guidelines. Earlier achievement of therapeutic antiplatelet effects by aspirin loading has long been considered the standard of care. However, the effects of the loading dose of aspirin (alone or in addition to a chronic maintenance oral dose) has not been studied in the contemporary era. A large proportion of myocardial cell death occurs upon and after reperfusion (so called, reperfusion injury). Numerous agents and interventions have been shown to limit infarct size in animal models when administered before or immediately after reperfusion. However, these interventions have predominantly failed to show significant protection in clinical studies. In the current review, we raise the hypothesis that aspirin loading may be the culprit. Data obtained from animal models consistently show that statins, ticagrelor, opiates and ischemic postconditioning limit myocardial infarct size. In most of these studies aspirin was not administered. However, when aspirin was administered before reperfusion (as is the case in the majority of studies enrolling STEMI patients), the protective effects of statins, ticagrelor, morphine and ischemic postconditioning were attenuated, which can be plausibly attributable to aspirin loading. We therefore suggest studying the effects of aspirin loading before reperfusion on the infarct size limiting effects of statins, ticagrelor, morphine and/ or postconditioning in large animal models using long reperfusion periods (at least 24h). If indeed aspirin attenuates the protective effects, clinical trials should be conducted comparing aspirin loading to alternative anti-platelet regimens without aspirin loading in patients with STEMI undergoing pPCI.