Tawny crazy ants (TCAs), Nylanderia fulva (Mayr) are an invasive species that develops extremely large populations that overrun landscapes. Control measures frequently rely on spraying contact insecticides, which often are inadequate. To provide insights for utilizing baits for their control, TCA foraging behavior was examined on liquid ant bait formulations that contained either fast-acting dinotefuran or slow-acting disodium octaborate tetrahydrate (DOT), and the impacts of these baits were assessed. Bayesian modeling of counts from time-lapse photography of TCA feeding on the baits and a control of sucrose solution in the field revealed strong evidence of similar foraging intensities between the control and the DOT bait and less foraging intensity on the dinotefuran bait. TCA abundance on the dinotefuran bait peaked within 8 h, then diminished to smaller feeding bouts over the 3-day study. In contrast, foraging on the DOT and control remained consistently high before bait depletion. The impact of the fast and slow-acting baits in field plots were based on TCA nest sizes and TCA abundance on sausage lures. Bayesian modeling predictions revealed nest sizes declined over the 2 months with bait present while the control had large nests. Abundance on the lures in the dinotefuran plots declined from the start of the study, while with the slow-acting DOT bait, declines in abundance were not lower than the control plot until 30 days after baiting was initiated. Further refinements in baiting with liquid baits containing fast and slow acting active ingredients may provide fast and sustained control of TCA.