Freshwater lakes are sentinels of environmental change, and climate change-driven declines in ice cover have been shown to disrupt aquatic communities and jeopardize ecosystem services. Viruses shape microbial communities and regulate biogeochemical cycles by acting as top-down controls, yet there is relatively little known about how declining ice cover will influence viral community activity. Lake Erie is a critical freshwater ecosystem and serves as a model system to assess how ice cover extent will affect winter limnology. We surveyed size selected surface water metatranscriptomes for conserved viral hallmark genes as a proxy for active virus populations and compared activity profiles between ice-covered and ice-free conditions from two contrasting winters. Active virus communities were present in both conditions, spanning diverse phylogenetic clades of bacteriophage (Caudovirales), giant viruses (Nucleocytoviricota), and RNA viruses (Orthornavirae). However, viral activity was significantly shaped by the extent of ice cover. Notably, viral richness and relative transcript abundance in the surface waters were reduced under ice relative to the ice-free conditions. Correlations with microbial community metrics suggest the differences in viral communities are at least in part driven by the decreased winter diatom bloom associated with declines in ice cover. Overall, our data suggest viral community activity is influenced by ice cover extent, and viruses may serve as sentinels of environmental disturbance and ecosystem response(s) to climate change.