Blastic plasmacytoid dendritic cell neoplasm (BPDCN) is a hematological malignancy characterized by recurrent skin nodules, an aggressive clinical course with rapid involvement of hematological organs, and a poor prognosis with overall survival. The rarity of the disease results in a few large-scale studies, a lack of controlled clinical trials for its management, and a lack of evidence-based guidelines. Here, we present a review of unmet clinical needs on the management of BPDCN by a panel of eleven experts involved in the research and clinical practice of BPDCN. Recommendations and proposals were achieved by multiple-step formalized procedures to reach a consensus after a comprehensive analysis of the scientific literature. The panel analyzed the critical issues of diagnostic pathway, prognostic stratification, therapy for young and fit patients and elderly and unfit patients, indication for allotransplant and for autotransplant, indication for central nervous system prophylaxis, and management of pediatric BPDCN patients. For each of these issues, consensus opinions were provided and, when appropriate, proposals for advancement in clinical practice were addressed. The hope is that this comprehensive overview will serve to improve the practice of BPDCN and inform the design and implementation of new studies in the field.