News Media and Peace Building in Asymmetrical Conflicts: The Flow of News between Jordan and Israel

Abstract

This study explores the role of the news media in asymmetrical conflicts after countries have signed a peace agreement. While most research has focused on the inherently negative role the press plays in attempts to bring peace, this study attempts to look at this issue using a more dynamic perspective. The theoretical argument focuses on how political factors affect the quantity and quality of the news flow and some of the ways in which leaders can sometimes overcome the obstacles they face in promoting encouraging news about peace. The model considers two political factors that have a major impact on media performance: the relative level of political power of the two sides and the varying amount of hostility. To illustrate the importance of these factors we focus on the flow of news between Jordan and Israel between 1999 and 2002. The major findings from content analyses of news articles (N = 859) appearing in both countries show that while Jordanians are exposed to massive amounts of mostly negative information about Israel, the Israeli public reads almost nothing about Jordan. Despite all this, it was also found that the initiation of diplomatic relations between the former enemies allowed for the creation of important ‘news slots’ that were previously unavailable. This development created space for less threatening types of news and also allowed leaders from both Jordan and Israel to initiate some positive stories about peace, even during some of the darkest periods.

Asymmetric war and asymmetric peace: Real realities and media realities in the Middle East and the Western Balkans

“…Such reforms are hardly ever as spectacular as other media-appealing facets of peacemaking, such as track-one diplomacy and peace treaty-signing rituals (Shinar, 2003;Wolfsfeld, 2004;Wolfsfeld, Alimi, & Kailani, 2008). This implies that in addition to the media, sustainable peace must be supported by the active involvement of the population, led by middle-range leadership, such as ethnic and religious activists, academics, and bottom-level support from grassroots organizations (Lederach, 1997).…”

The Media and Post-Election Peacebuilding in Nigeria, 1999–2015

“…Although these media participatory platforms have been effective with increased elite participation, there is a large number of marginalized people in rural areas, including females and the poorest of the poor, who have zero access to media engagement due to lack of electricity or inability to afford televisions. In any case, there is every reason to believe that the discussions are likely to have significant effect on the polity, especially attempts at reconciliation and peacebuilding (Wolfsfeld, Alimi, and Kailani 2008) and the building of relationships between the populations involved (Lederach 1998).…”

Los Medios De Comunicación Como Actores (Des) Legitimadores. Algunas Reflexiones Acerca Del Rol De Los Medios De Comunicación Sobre La Construcción De La Opinión Pública en Torno Al Proceso De Paz De La Habana

“…En la misma línea Wolsfeld, Eitan y Wasfi afirman que "un proceso de paz exitoso requiere de paciencia, y los medios demandan inmediatez. Lograr paz es más factible en un entorno tranquilo y los medios tienen un interés obsesivo sobre las amenazas y la violencia" (Wolsfeld, Eitan, & Wasfki, 2008).…”