Newspaper media reporting of motor vehicle crashes in Singapore: an opportunity lost for injury prevention education?

Abstract

Newspaper media advocacy can help steer public attention away from motor vehicle crash (MVC) injuries as a personal problem to that of a social and public health issue. If used properly, newspaper media is potentially a powerful mass educator on MVC prevention. However, there is often a conflict of interest in which newspapers, in an attempt to boost readership and revenue, may over-emphasize and sensationalize the human-interest aspect of an MVC story. The aim of this study is to examine newspaper articles of MVCs in Singapore to assess how our newspaper media coverage portray MVCs and identify factors that mitigate injury and educate the public on injury prevention measures. Details of the MVC were extracted from 12 months of newspaper coverage in Singapore. Two independent coders were used to establish inter-rater reliability. From 1 January to 31 December 2007, 201 articles about MVCs were published. About 74.1% of articles assigned blame to a particular road user, negligence on either road user was implied in 56.7% of articles, and road safety messages were mentioned in 8% of the articles. The mainstream communication tone used was positive for law enforcement (71.1%) and neutral towards injury prevention or road safety messages (89.1%). Newspaper media reporting of MVCs in Singapore generally does not include injury prevention messages or highlight injury-mitigating measures. This is a lost opportunity for public education. Collaboration between public health practitioners and newspaper media is required to address this issue.

What we are not talking about: An evaluation of prevention messaging in print media reporting on agricultural injuries and fatalities

“…We believe a natural result of collaboration between agricultural safety agencies and media would be that appropriate information would be received by the right audience to use that information, facilitating behavioral change. It would also expand the role of print media to provide a public health service, and we echo calls made by other researchers for this [Rosales and Stallones, 2008;Heng and Vasu, 2010]. Print media is one vehicle for this but integration of messages into a societal context is key, otherwise we risk spinning our wheels and not moving forward at reducing the burden of agricultural injury.…”

Agenda Setting for Health Promotion: Exploring an Adapted Model for the Social Media Era

“…From the viewpoint of health promotion, agenda setting is an effective approach to achieving best practice aims and objectives [ 10 , 11 , 12 ]. Agenda setting can hold more potential than behavioral change strategies, as confirmed by road safety research and interventions [ 33 , 84 , 85 ]. This is demonstrated through the impact of influencing social policies [ 84 , 86 ], persuading policy and decision makers [ 7 ], orienting media coverage [ 11 ], enhancing the advocacy process, and maximizing the diffusion of innovations [ 12 ].…”

Geospatial analysis of severe road traffic accidents in Singapore in 2013–2014

“…The mainstream media in Singapore can also play a greater role in public education on trauma and RTAs. (27) Social media has, in recent years, begun to emerge as a powerful tool in education, and generating public interest and its importance cannot be ignored.…”