In pediatric diabetology, a precise diagnosis is very important because it allows early and correct clinical management of the patient. Monogenic diabetes (MD), which accounts for 1–6% of all pediatric–adolescent diabetes cases, is the most relevant example of precision medicine. The definitive diagnosis of MD, possible only by genetic testing, allows us to direct patients to more appropriate therapy in relation to the identified mutation. In some cases, MD patients can avoid insulin and be treated with oral hypoglycemic drugs with a perceptible impact on both the quality of life and the healthcare costs. However, the genetic and phenotypic heterogeneity of MD and the overlapping clinical characteristics between different forms, can complicate the diagnostic process. In recent years, the development of Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS) methodology, which allows the simultaneous analysis of multiple genes, has revolutionized molecular diagnostics, becoming the cornerstone of MD precision diagnosis. We report two cases of patients with clinical suspects of MD in which a genetic test was carried out, using a NGS multigenic panel, and it clarified the correct pathogenesis of diabetes, allowing us to better manage the disease both in probands and other affected family members.