A widely appreciated principle is that all reactions are fundamentally reversible. Observing reversible transition metal-catalyzed reactions, particularly those that include the cleavage of C–C bonds, are more challenging. The development of the palladium- and nickel-catalyzed carboiodination reactions afforded access to the syn- and anti-diastereomers of the iodo-dihydroisoquinolone products. Using these substrates, an extensive study investigating the catalytic reversibility of the C–C bond formation using a different palladium catalyst was undertaken. A combination of experimental and computational studies led to the discovery of a variety of new methodologies and concepts key to understanding the process of reversible C–C bond formations.