Climate change mitigation requires creative solutions to reduce greenhouse gases (GHG). Little research has been performed on GHG emissions from shaded turfgrass systems, resulting in a lack of best management practice (BMP) development. The aim of this research was to investigate the soil flux of carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), and nitrous oxide (N2O) as impacted by shade [shade (98.8%) versus sun (100%)] and differing sources (fast- versus slow-release) and rates (147 versus 294 kg ha−1 yr−1) of nitrogen (N) fertilizers on creeping bentgrass putting greens. The results show that emissions of soil CO2 and soil N2O are significantly lower in shaded plots versus sunny plots. The presence of N fertilizer significantly increased soil CO2 emissions over unfertilized plots. Quick-release N fertilizer fluxed significantly more soil N2O than the slow-release N fertilizers. Turfgrass color was significantly higher on the sunny green versus the shaded green except in late summer. Turfgrass quality was significantly higher for the shaded green versus the sunny green. Milorganite improved turfgrass quality whereas urea decreased turfgrass quality due to fertilizer burn. When N is needed to improve turfgrass color and quality, the use of slow-release N sources should be a BMP for shaded greens.