‘No Room for Religion or Spirituality or Cooking Tips’: Exploring Practical Atheism as an Unspoken Consensus in the Development of Social Work Values in England

Abstract

Academic interest in the subject of social work and religion is a relatively new phenomenon in Britain. This article draws on material derived from a doctorate on the history, development and current practice of church-based social work in Britain to examine the reasons for the absence of debate on this topic dating back to professional social work's earliest days. It takes Alistair McFayden's concept of 'practical atheism' and shows how, in different ways, this concept has been prevalent in church-based social work. It argues that social work in England (rather than Britain as a whole) has been secular in part by default, because those who might be expected to oppose such a position have, for a number of reasons, failed to do so. The result has been an absence of debate concerning matters of religion, replaced instead by an unspoken but widespread practical atheism. The secular humanism found within English social work has never been required to define itself, to test itself against a position that argues for a social work suffused with theological insights. The article concludes that a more open debate on this topic would be of benefit to all concerned.

The Effect of Religion on Parenting in Order to Guide Parents in the Way They Parent: A Systematic Review

“…Religious beliefs, however, continue to generate unease, lack of genuine engagement, a "low level of acceptance" (Furman, Benson, & Canda, 2004, p. 813), and disrespect amongst scholars as well as within ranks of professionals, including social workers (Hodge, 2005;Streets, 2009;Thyer & Myers, 2009;Whiting, 2008). There is a good deal of historical evidence to suggest that religion possesses the capacity to socialize, motivate, constrain, and direct human behavior (Smith, Denton, Faris, & Regnerus, 2002;Smith, 2003).…”

Protecting Children from Faith-Based Abuse through Accusations of Witchcraft and Spirit Possession: Understanding Contexts and Informing Practice

“…When responding to suspected cases of abuse, it is important for practitioners to acknowledge that their own views about religion are likely to influence their practice (Horwarth and Lees, 2010). Practitioners, perhaps applying 'pragmatic atheism' (Whiting 2008) The discovery of new aspects of child abuse is inevitably accompanied by a desire to find ways of easily identifying cases, through recognised signs and symptoms. Though some signs can be listed as relevant to abuse arising from faith-based beliefs in witchcraft and spirit possession, it would be unhelpful to rely on these alone when making assessments.…”

Addiction, spirituality and 12-step programmes

“…Whiting (2008) argues there is an unspoken secular humanism at the heart of social work practice. Coupled with a possible suspicion of the spiritual, Collins and Cummins (2002) described social workers as lacking training in the area of addictions recovery, and this has been affirmed more recently by a Scottish Government Report (2011).…”