“No thanks, I don’t want to see snakes again”: a qualitative study of pain management versus preservation of cognition in palliative care patients

Abstract

Background Towards the end of life, use of opioid analgesics becomes more common in patients to control pain and improve quality of life. While pain medication may help manage pain, unwanted cognitive side effects are frequently noted. This balancing act presents a trade-off for patients between pain relief and adverse effects, where the desire to relieve pain must be evaluated against the desire to maintain cognitive clarity and may represent a difficult decision for patients receiving palliative care. Our goal was to understand how patients’ decision making about pain medications balances the pain relief from those medications against the cognitive decline often associated with them. Methods We conducted qualitative semi-structured interviews with patients receiving home-based palliative care from a program in Toronto, Canada. Interview recordings were transcribed and analyzed using thematic analysis. Results Thirty-one interviews were conducted. Some patients preferred cognitive preservation over pain management because of a sense that cognition is central to their identity, the desire to maintain lucidity, a desire to continue participating in work or hobbies, and fear of addiction. Conversely, some patients preferred pain management over cognitive preservation because of a desire to avoid suffering, an inability to sleep without medications, or an acceptance of some cognitive compromise. A few patients attempted to find balance through tapering drugs, limiting their use of breakthrough analgesic doses, or using alternative strategies. Conclusions Decision making around pain and pain management is a highly preference-sensitive process—with no clear right or wrong decisions, only the preferences of each patient. The findings from this study may influence the design of future patient-facing decision aids around pain management. Future studies should pilot interventions to better assist patients with this decision.

Palliative Care and End-of-Life Issues in Patients with Brain Cancer Admitted to ICU

“…Every patient may have personal priorities and beliefs and, according to them, goals of care can be established. For example, the use of opioids can be a great resource against pain, but it can also compromise daily mental faculties, such that some patient would prefer a lower level of pain management in order to keep their complete mental faculties unmodified [ 25 ].…”

The role of qualification and quality management in the prescription of antipsychotics and potentially inappropriate medication (PIM) in nursing home residents in Germany: results of the HIOPP-3-iTBX study

“…Untreated pain is considered to be one of the causes of challenging behavior, such as agitation or aggression in people with dementia [ 50 ]. On the other hand, in some cases, cognitive impairment may worsen under analgesic medication [ 51 , 52 ]. Interprofessional collaboration in medication management, therefore, is necessary for the management of pain in NHR.…”

“That Little Bit of Time”: Transition-to-Hospice Perspectives From Hospice Staff and Bereaved Family

“…Previous research with caregivers of home hospice patients reveals that caregivers and families need improved education and support regarding opioid dosage and use ( McFarlane & Liu, 2020 ). Misconceptions about pain medications in hospice are common and stigma around morphine may make caregivers apprehensive about giving medicine out of fear of opioid dependence or hastened death ( Ho et al, 2020 ; Lau et al, 2009 ; Noh, 2019 ; Wegier et al, 2020 ).…”