“…Note that the 2-D flow structures mentioned here are very similar to those observed in 2-D RB convection, however, quite different from the 2-D Taylor column structures occurring for RB convection rotating about the vertical axis with large angular velocity (Grooms et al 2010;Chong et al 2020a). Two-dimensional simulations, which are computationally more accessible than 3-D simulations, have also been widely used to study thermal convection with no-slip plates in recent years (Johnston & Doering 2009;Sugiyama et al 2010;Huang & Zhou 2013;van der Poel et al 2015b;Zhu et al 2018a;Wang et al 2019b;Zhu et al 2019;Chong et al 2020b;Wan et al 2020;Wang, Zhou & Sun 2020a;Yang et al 2020). In van der Poel, Stevens & Lohse (2013), 2-D and 3-D simulations are compared in detail, and many similarities are found for Pr 1.…”