Cell death can be executed by regulated apoptotic and non-apoptotic pathways, including the iron-dependent process of ferroptosis. Small molecules are essential tools for studying the regulation of cell death. Using live-cell, time-lapse imaging, and a library of 1,833 small molecules including FDA-approved drugs and investigational agents, we assemble a large compendium of kinetic cell death 'modulatory profiles' for inducers of apoptosis and ferroptosis. From this dataset we identified dozens of small molecule inhibitors of ferroptosis, including numerous investigational and FDA-approved drugs with unexpected off-target antioxidant or iron chelating activities. ATP-competitive mechanistic target of rapamycin (mTOR) inhibitors, by contrast, were on-target ferroptosis inhibitors. Further investigation revealed both mTOR-dependent and mTOR-independent mechanisms linking amino acid levels to the regulation of ferroptosis sensitivity in cancer cells. These results highlight widespread bioactive compound pleiotropy and link amino acid sensing to the regulation of ferroptosis.