Noncognitive Skills and the Gender Disparities in Test Scores and Teacher Assessments: Evidence from Primary School

Abstract

Non-cognitive Skills and the Gender Disparities in Test Scores and Teacher Assessments: Evidence from Primary School We extend the analysis of early-emerging gender differences in academic achievement to include both (objective) test scores and (subjective) teacher assessments. Using data from the 1998-99 ECLS-K cohort, we show that the grades awarded by teachers are not aligned with test scores, with the disparities in grading exceeding those in testing outcomes and uniformly favoring girls, and that the misalignment of grades and test scores can be linked to gender differences in non-cognitive development. Girls in every racial category outperform boys on reading tests and the differences are statistically significant in every case except for black fifth-graders. Boys score at least as well on math and science tests as girls, with the strongest evidence of a gender gap appearing among whites. However, boys in all racial categories across all subject areas are not represented in grade distributions where their test scores would predict. Even those boys who perform equally as well as girls on reading, math and science tests are nevertheless graded less favorably by their teachers, but this less favorable treatment essentially vanishes when non-cognitive skills are taken into account. White boys who perform on par with white girls on these subject-area tests and exhibit the same non-cognitive skill level are graded similarly. For some specifications there is evidence of a grade "bonus" for white boys with test scores and behavior like their girl counterparts. While the evidence is a little weaker for blacks and Hispanics, the message is essentially the same.

Leaving Boys Behind

“…The higher average grades of girls are at times equated with their higher average noncognitive abilities (Jacob 2002;Becker, Hubbard, and Murphy 2010). Alternatively, Cornwell, Mustard, and Van Parys (2013) argue that discrepancies between test scores and grades by gender are due to discrimination by teachers. If teachers discriminate on the basis of classroom behavior rather than pure gender preference, grades would incorporate some noncognitive abilities.…”

Ecological and Evolutionary Principles for Secondary Education: Analyzing Career and Tech Ed

“…Finally, because males tend to be farther toward the fast end of the life history spectrum than females, they will likely be overrepresented among those experiencing such outcomes. Indeed, recent literature suggests that on average, males have poorer academic achievement and more discipline occurrences in primary school (Cornwell et al 2013), have greater incidence of high school dropout (Heckman and LaFontaine 2010), and are less likely to graduate college (Goldin et al 2006).…”

Who Believes in Me? The Effect of Student-Teacher Demographic Match on Teacher Expectations

“…One channel through which teachers likely influence students' beliefs is via grading (Mechtenberg 2009). Indeed, robust evidence suggests gender, racial, and ethnic biases in how teachers grade exams in a variety of contexts (Burgess and Greaves 2013;Cornwell, Mustard, and Van Parys 2013;Hanna and Linden 2012;Lavy 2008). Lavy and Sand (2015) show that grading biases can have long-lasting impacts on academic achievement and course taking in high school.…”