Semi-crystalline polymers exhibit broad and multiple peaks in their melting traces. Thus, the melting temperature characteristics of polymers should consider both melting peak positions and melting temperature polydispersity. In this work, the effective melting temperature and temperature polydispersity are defined and calculated from DSC traces, using the crystal size number distribution and the melting temperature equation. Three methods are proposed for calculating melting temperature characteristics. These methods are based on: (i) average crystal size, (ii) the crystal stem number distribution function, and (iii) the monomer structural unit distribution function. They were employed to analyze the isothermal and non-isothermal experimental results for polyethylene polymers, especially linear low-density polyethylene copolymers. The first method, based on the value of average crystal size, gives the most reasonable results, taking into consideration agreement with experimental observations and structural data.