“…Despite good agreement in the present study, it should be noted that the linear potential theory cannot elucidate the primary physics in some cases. One exception is liquid sloshing in an upright circular tank (Liang, Santo, Shao, Law, & Chan, 2020; Liu, Shao, Chen, & Liang, 2022; Tan, Shao, & Read, 2019), in which non-planar waves occur due to modal interactions. In this case, the nonlinearity of sloshing flow must be accounted for.…”