Normal variation of magnetic resonance T1 relaxation times in the human population at 1.5 T using ShMOLLI

Abstract

BackgroundQuantitative T1-mapping is rapidly becoming a clinical tool in cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR) to objectively distinguish normal from diseased myocardium. The usefulness of any quantitative technique to identify disease lies in its ability to detect significant differences from an established range of normal values. We aimed to assess the variability of myocardial T1 relaxation times in the normal human population estimated with recently proposed Shortened Modified Look-Locker Inversion recovery (ShMOLLI) T1 mapping technique.MethodsA large cohort of healthy volunteers (n = 342, 50% females, age 11–69 years) from 3 clinical centres across two countries underwent CMR at 1.5T. Each examination provided a single average myocardial ShMOLLI T1 estimate using manually drawn myocardial contours on typically 3 short axis slices (average 3.4 ± 1.4), taking care not to include any blood pool in the myocardial contours. We established the normal reference range of myocardial and blood T1 values, and assessed the effect of potential confounding factors, including artefacts, partial volume, repeated measurements, age, gender, body size, hematocrit and heart rate.ResultsNative myocardial ShMOLLI T1 was 962 ± 25 ms. We identify the partial volume as primary source of potential error in the analysis of respective T1 maps and use 1 pixel erosion to represent “midwall myocardial” T1, resulting in a 0.9% decrease to 953 ± 23 ms. Midwall myocardial ShMOLLI T1 was reproducible with an intra-individual, intra- and inter-scanner variability of ≤2%. The principle biological parameter influencing myocardial ShMOLLI T1 was the female gender, with female T1 longer by 24 ms up to the age of 45 years, after which there was no significant difference from males. After correction for age and gender dependencies, heart rate was the only other physiologic factor with a small effect on myocardial ShMOLLI T1 (6ms/10bpm). Left and right ventricular blood ShMOLLI T1 correlated strongly with each other and also with myocardial T1 with the slope of 0.1 that is justifiable by the resting partition of blood volume in myocardial tissue. Overall, the effect of all variables on myocardial ShMOLLI T1 was within 2% of relative changes from the average.ConclusionNative T1-mapping using ShMOLLI generates reproducible and consistent results in normal individuals within 2% of relative changes from the average, well below the effects of most acute forms of myocardial disease. The main potential confounder is the partial volume effect arising from over-inclusion of neighbouring tissue at the manual stages of image analysis. In the study of cardiac conditions such as diffuse fibrosis or small focal changes, the use of “myocardial midwall” T1, age and gender matching, and compensation for heart rate differences may all help to improve the method sensitivity in detecting subtle changes. As the accuracy of current T1 measurement methods remains to be established, this study does not claim to report an accurate measure of T1, but that ShMOLLI is a stab...

Accuracy of Parenchymal Cerebral Blood Flow Measurements Using Pseudocontinuous Arterial Spin-Labeling in Healthy Volunteers

“…Using equation 3 in the Appendix and T 1b for men and for women, we estimated that the relative sex difference in pCBF ASL values in our data decreased from 12% to approximately 4%, which then is less than the PCMRI findings. In the same study, Piechnik et al 40 found no differences in T1 b values between HY (20 -30 years) and HE (60 -70 years) subjects, which indicates that the T1 b effect is not the dominating factor in explaining the large effect of aging on pCBF ASL . Motion artifacts during the ASL scan were not corrected, which might be a source of error in the pCBF ASL estimates.…”

“…26,37 Previous studies have shown higher mean T1 b values (6%-9%) in women than in men, and the lower blood hematocrit level in women than in men may explain this observed sex difference in mean T1 b . [38][39][40] In a previous study, Piechnik et al 40 found significantly higher mean T1 b values in women than in men (1577 vs 1491 ms, respectively). Using equation 3 in the Appendix and T 1b for men and for women, we estimated that the relative sex difference in pCBF ASL values in our data decreased from 12% to approximately 4%, which then is less than the PCMRI findings.…”

Aortic Stiffness and Interstitial Myocardial Fibrosis by Native T1 Are Independently Associated With Left Ventricular Remodeling in Patients With Dilated Cardiomyopathy

“…This result concords with our own findings in a larger and multicenter cohort of healthy subjects, 33 as well accords with the subanalysis in subjects with low prevalence of cardiovascular risk factors in Multiethnic Study of Atherosclerosis (MESA) study (albeit reporting on extracellular volume fraction). 34 Piechnik et al 35 showed a mild inverse relationship between native T1 and age. Contrary to controls, native T1 increases with age in the presence of disease, suggesting a cumulative effect of disease process with time.…”

Cardiac Magnetic Resonance T1 Mapping in Cardiomyopathies

“…Modern in-line processing provides registration tools to reduce motion artifacts before the computation of final T1 maps (motion-corrected or "MoCo MOLLI") [27]. A shortened Modified Look-Locker inversion recovery (shMOLLI) with shorter breath-holds has been validated and recently applied for cardiomyopathies [28,29].…”