North-African doctors as second victims of medical errors: a cross sectional survey

Abstract

Introduction Physicians involved in medical errors (MEs) can experience loss of self-esteem and negative psychological experiences. They are called “second victims” of the ME. Aims To i) describe the profile, the types and the severity of MEs, and ii) explore the psychological impact on “second victims” to better understand how they cope. Methods It was a cross sectional retrospective study conducted from March to August 2018. All physicians working at Farhat Hached and Sahloul University hospitals were asked to complete a questionnaire about their possible MEs. The impact of MEs was evaluated using the Impact of Event Scale-Revised (IES-R) (scoring, 0–88) (subscales ranges; intrusion, (0–32); avoidance, (0–32); hyperarousal, (0–24)). The diagnosis of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) was made when the total IES-R score exceeded 33. The coping strategies were evaluated using Ways of Coping Checklist Revised (WCC-R) scale (scoring, problem-focused, (10–40); emotion focused, (9–36); seeking social support, (8–32)). Results Among 393 responders, 268(68.2%) reported MEs. Wrong diagnosis (40.5%), faulty treatment (34.6%), preventive errors (13.5%) and faulty communication (6.4%) were the main frequent types of MEs. The most common related causes of MEs were inexperience (47.3%) and job overload (40.2%). The physicians’ median (range) score of the IES-R was 19(0–69). According to the IES-R score, the most frequent psychological impacts were median (range): intrusion, 7(0–28) and avoidance symptoms, 7(0–24). PTSD symptoms affected 23.5% of physicians. Female sex and serious MEs were identified as predictors of PTSD. On the WCC-R check list, coping was balanced between the three coping strategies median (range), problem focused, 28.5(10–40); emotion-focused, 24(9–36) and seeking social support 21(8–32). Conclusion There is a relatively high impact of ME within these North-African university hospital physicians. Coping was balanced within different three strategies as reported worldwide. Physicians adopted more likely constructive changes than defensive ones.

Healthcare Students and Medical Residents as Second Victims: A Cross-Sectional Study

“…We did not find any relevant data about effective interventions already implemented. However, since these symptoms closely resemble post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) [12,25], we think that when defining a potential intervention towards PSIs involving healthcare students, a PTSD program should be considered. As an example, psychological therapy, self-help programs, and even drug therapies may be considered, because of their effectiveness towards PTSD in veterans [26,27].…”

Burden and Patterns of Medical Emergencies during Ramadan Fasting: A Narrative Review

“…7 8 9 10 11 12 13 The salient findings of these and other studies are discussed below. 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20…”

“…While there were no differences in any studied outcomes in patients admitted to ICU before, during, or after Ramadan, there was a significant increase in patients presenting with a history of CKD, hypovolemic shock, and inverted urinary sodium to potassium ratio. 18…”

Second Victims in Maternity Care – The Hidden Fallout of Parental Birth Plans

“…Even when no clinical harm occurs, midwives and doctors suffer from stress and anxiety for the 'nearmiss' of things that could so easily have happened. And when things do go wrong, they suffer a sense of guilt and responsibility, which can be so severe that it can lead to enduring depression or anxiety and, for some, the loss of careers or even life [12].…”

“…They become weary and defensive; they feel vulnerable. For some, it may force an involuntary retirement, a change in career or an inability to work because of ongoing stress [12]. When we invited feedback, we were told how important it was to talk about this, but people don't feel they can; they think they're not allowed to do so.…”