Not by Ganglion Cells Alone: Directional Selectivity is Widespread in Identified Cells of the Turtle Retina

Two well-stained, horseradish peroxidase-filled varieties of putative ON-OFF directionally selective ganglion cells, G14a and G15, that project to the dorsolateral optic tectum (Guiloff and Kolb [1992a] Vis. Neurosci. 8:295-313) were studied qualitatively and quantitatively. Both were bistratified ganglion cells with one tier of dendrites in the OFF sublamina and the other in the ON sublamina of the inner plexiform layer (IPL). The cells were serially sectioned and examined for synaptic inputs by electron microscopy. Portions of the dendritic trees were also analyzed after postembedding immunocytochemistry for neurotransmitter candidates gamma aminobutyric acid (GABA), glycine, choline acetyltransferase (ChAT), and glutamate in presynaptic neurons. Both G14a and G15 are dominated by amacrine cell inputs and have only minor bipolar cell involvement. Probably at least two different types of bipolar cell are presynaptic. Both ganglion cells receive some GABA-positive (GABA+) amacrine inputs and G14a receives ChAT+ amacrine inputs. Glycine+ and glutamate+ inputs could not be detected in either cell. The GABA+ inputs appeared to be regionally arranged in the dendritic trees. The general distribution of amacrine and bipolar inputs to the two tiers of dendrites in both cell types appeared to be asymmetrical, both along the radial extent of the dendritic trees and within the depth of the IPL. Our data support some aspects of the current models for directional selectivity. We suggest candidate bipolar and amacrine cells that could have input to these ganglion cells. Since many of the putative presynaptic amacrine cells coincide with directionally selective types recorded and stained by other authors, we propose that in turtle retina directional selectivity arises in neurons presynaptic to the ganglion cells.

“…1). This G15 cell closely resembles the cell of Figure 1 in DeVoe and co-authors' chapter (DeVoe et al, 1989).…”

Section: Ganglion Cell 615mentioning

confidence: 60%

mentioning

confidence: 84%

mentioning

confidence: 87%

mentioning

confidence: 95%

See 2 more Smart Citations

Ultrastructural and immunocytochemical analysis of the circuitry of two putative directionally selective ganglion cells in turtle retina

Guiloff

Kolb

1994

“…All subsequent investigations have confirmed and elaborated on the importance of directional selectivity (DS) and motion detection in the turtle retina (Schwartz, 1973;Marchiafava, 1979;Bowling, 1980;Jensen and DeVoe, 1983;Criswell, 1987;DeVoe et al, 1989;Granda and Fulbrook, 1989). Moreover, it has become clear that these types of responses are not only confined to ganglion cells.…”

mentioning

confidence: 82%

The organization of the turtle inner retina. II. Analysis of color‐coded and directionally selective cells

Ammermüller

Kolb

1995

Color coding and directional selectivity (DS) of retinal neurons were studied in the Pseudemys turtle by using similar intracellular recording and staining techniques as in the preceding paper (J. Ammermüller and H. Kolb, 1995, J. Comp. Neuronal. 358:1-34). Color-coded responses were elicited by red (621 or 694 nm), green (525 or 514 nm), and blue (455 nm) light flashes. In addition to red/green and yellow/blue types of chromaticity horizontal cells, in our sample of 305 identified cells we found that 17% of bipolar cells, 6.5% of amacrine cells, and 18% of ganglion cells exhibit color-coded responses. DS responses were found in 37% of the tested ganglion cells and 41% of the tested amacrine cells. Two morphologically identified bipolar cell types, B10 and B11, were red-ON/blue-OFF and red-OFF/green, blue-ON, respectively. Of five identified amacrine cell types, three were red-OFF/blue-ON center (A1, A3, A23b), one was red-OFF/green-ON center (A32), and one (A33) was double color-opponent of red-ON/blue-OFF center:red-OFF/blue-ON surround. Five ganglion cell types had variously color-coded centers (G14 and G24) or surrounds (G3 and G18), including one type, G6, that was double color-opponent (red-OFF/green-ON center:red-ON/green-OFF surround). Responses to colors were found primarily in sustained responses of bipolar and ganglion cells. However, in amacrine cells, transient components of the response also showed color dependence. Red-OFF-center responses were found in ganglion cells that were in a position to make connections at the strata 2/3 border with the red-OFF bipolar cell (B11); red-ON-center responses occurred in ganglion cells with branches in stratum 4 of the IPL where the red-ON-center bipolar (B10) ended. Blue-ON-center signals appeared to be processed mainly in strata 1-2/3, and blue-OFF-center signals in strata 3-5 of the IPL, with contributions of amacrine cells and bipolar cells. Labeled DS amacrine cells could be identified as A9, A20, and A22, and ganglion cells as G19, G20, and G24. The latter type (G24) showed DS and color coding. All response types (ON-center, OFF-center, ON-OFF) were encountered. DS amacrine cells were monostratified near the middle of the IPL, whereas DS ganglion cells were mono-, bi-, and multistratified, although all DS ganglion cells had one feature in common: they had dendrites in stratum 1 of the IPL.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Synaptic organization of starburst amacrine cells in rabbit retina: Analysis of serial thin sections by electron microscopy and graphic reconstruction

Famiglietti

1991

191

236

The synaptic organization of starburst amacrine cells was studied by electron microscopy of individual or overlapping pairs of Golgi-impregnated cells. Both type a and type b cells were analyzed, the former with normally placed somata and dendritic branching in sublamina a, and the latter with somata displaced to the ganglion cell layer and branching in sublamina b. Starburst amacrine cells were thin-sectioned horizontally, tangential to the retinal surface, and electron micrographs of each section in a series were taken en montage. Cell bodies and dendritic trees were reconstructed graphically from sets of photographic montages representing the serial sections. Synaptic inputs from cone bipolar cells and amacrine cells are distributed sparsely and irregularly all along the dendritic tree. Sites of termination include the synaptic boutons of starburst amacrine cells, which lie at the perimeter of the dendritic tree in the "distal dendritic zone." In central retina, bipolar cell input is associated with very small dendritic spines near the cell body in the "proximal dendritic zone." The proximal dendrites of type a and type b cells generally lie in planes or "strata" of the inner plexiform layer (IPL), near the margins of the IPL. The boutons and varicosities of starburst amacrine cells, distributed int he distal dendritic zone, lie in the "starburst substrata," which occupy a narrow middle region in each of the two sublaminae, a and b, in rabbit retina. As a consequence of differences in stratification, proximal and distal dendritic zones are potentially subject to different types of input. Type b starburst amacrines do not receive inputs from rod bipolar terminals, which lie mainly in the inner marginal zone of the IPL (stratum 5), but type a cells receive some input from the lobular presynaptic appendages of rod amacrine cells in sublamina a, at the border of strata 1 and 2. There is good correspondence between boutons or varicosities and synaptic outputs of starburst amacrine cells, but not all boutons gave ultrastructural evidence of presynaptic junctions. The boutons and varicosities may be both pre- and postsynaptic. They are postsynaptic to cone bipolar cell and amacrine cell terminals, and presynaptic primarily to ganglion cell dendrites. In two pairs of type b starburst amacrine cells with overlapping dendritic fields, close apposition of synaptic boutons was observed, raising the possibility of synaptic contact between them. The density of the Golgi-impregnation and other technical factors prevented definite resolution of this question. No unimpregnated profiles, obviously amacrine in origin, were found postsynaptic to the impregnated starburst boutons.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)