"Not Unto Nomination": Dickinson at the Limits of Philology

I t w o u ld be te m p tin g to say th a t th e U n iv ersity of Iow a b ro u g h t th e w o rd workshop in to o u r la n g u ag e, b u t th a t w o u ld n o t be tru e. It is tru e th a t The American Heritage Dictionary, w ith p u b lic a tio n d a te s th a t b e g in in 1969, offers as its se c o n d d e fin itio n of workshop, " a g ro u p of p e o p le w h o m e e t reg u la rly for a se m in a r in so m e sp ecialized field: a creative-writing workshop." A n d it is e q u a lly tru e th a t th e m o d e rn u se of workshop, in th a t se n se , a n d creative w riting as w ell, can b e st be tra c ed to h e re. B ut workshop h a s a m u c h o ld er h isto ry , a n d a d is tin g u is h e d o n e, to w h ic h o u r u n iv e rs ity h a s b u t a d d e d. Its first citatio n (1582) in th e Oxford English Dictio nary refers to A le x a n d er th e G reat h a n g in g o u t in th e w o rk s h o p of th e fo u rth c e n tu ry B.C. G reek p a in te r, A pelles. Workshop is a c u rio u s term , o n e th a t cro sses a rt w ith m a n u a l labor. " S h o p " d e riv e s from th e O ld E n g lish , sceoppa, w h ic h m e a n t a " b o o th " o r " sta ll," as in a m a rk e t. T h ere is a w o rk in g-class feel to th e w o rd th a t e n jo y s lo n g s ta n d in g. B ut O ld E nglish weorc, also m e a n t a n " a c t" o r " d e e d " as w ell as its obvious cognate; a n d so, d e p e n d in g o n h o w o n e feels a b o u t it, m an u a l labor is e ith e r g ra n te d a ce rtain d ig n ity , e v e n n o b ility as a " d e e d ," o r d e e d s of h ig h c u ltu ral s ta n d in g color th e m se lv e s favorably w ith th e p a tin a of h a n d so n labor. " W o rk " in tu rn d eriv ed , so th e lex ic o g ra p h e rs tell u s, fro m a n In d o-E u ro p e a n root, werg, w h ic h is re la te d to th e G reek ergon, m e a n in g " w o rk " or " a c tio n ." Werg sh o w s u p in " e n e rg y ," " a lle rg y ," " litu rg y ," "g eo rg ic," a n d " s u rg e ry ," to n a m e b u t a few , as it also d o e s in " o rg a n " a n d " o rg y ." Each of th e s e w o rd s h a s b e e n called u p o n at o n e tim e or a n o th e r to d escrib e a n a sp e c t of o u r W o rk sh o p. S ettled in to a n a g ric u ltu ra l a rea, it h a s b e e n s e e n b y so m e as h o p e le ssly lo st in th e " g e o rg ic ." B ut o n e can com e h e re a n d

show abstract

Dickinson’s Delight

Zapędowska¹

2012

edj

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Although Dickinson’s writings explore a variety of affects and psychological states, she is often seen as a poet of pain, lack, and despair. By contrast, this essay argues that Dickinson views delight as the primary affect that creates the basis for all other feelings. Throughout her career Dickinson tests the expressive and representational limits of language against an excess of happiness, and she meditates on happiness when it eludes her. Emmanuel Levinas’s idea that selfhood originates in happiness helps to elucidate both the importance of delight in Dickinson’s poetry and Dickinson’s insistence that poetic subjectivity originates in amplitude rather than lack. Her early poems of delight reveal a subjectivity happily immersed in the elemental world, secure in its happiness, drawing strength from the most basic, physical level of being. This happy, empowered subjectivity never entirely disappears from Dickinson’s poetry. While scholars of female sentimentalism have demonstrated that physical pain offers nineteenth-century American women a culturally acceptable opportunity for embodiment, Dickinson shows that delight provides an alternative opportunity to experience the body through sensual satisfaction. Moreover, Dickinson asserts that female creativity arises from an emotional, intellectual, and verbal abundance that demands to be expressed in language. This insistence on delight allows Dickinson to affirm female poetic subjectivity, which many of her female contemporaries found problematic.

show abstract

scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.

Contact Info

customersupport@researchsolutions.com

10624 S. Eastern Ave., Ste. A-614

Henderson, NV 89052, USA

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Blog Terms and Conditions API Terms Privacy Policy Contact Cookie Preferences Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information

Made with 💙 for researchers

Part of the Research Solutions Family.

"Not Unto Nomination": Dickinson at the Limits of Philology

Cited by 3 publications

References 9 publications

Index to Volumes I-XIII (1992-2004)

Index to Volumes I-XIII (1992-2004)

How(e) to Read Dickinson (W)riting Nature

Dickinson’s Delight

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About