Through predation and displacement, the Cape fur seal Arctocephalus pusillus pusillus poses a threat to several seabird species that breed in southern Africa. Measures such as the culling of 'problem' seals have been introduced to negate the effects on these species, but there have been calls for stronger measures to be taken against seals. In this review, past evidence for direct impacts of seals on seabird populations was scrutinised. It was found that frequently the interpretation of seabird numer ical trends, or of anecdotes on seal-seabird interactions, appear biased against seals. It is mooted that, as with seal-fishery interactions, the conspicuous nature of seals and some of their behaviour may have resulted in their effects on seabird colonies or populations being over-emphasised in the past. The poor conservation status of the impacted seabird species has been influenced by numerous factors, foremost of which are human interference and historical bad management practices. Culling or displacing of seals, at any scale, are unlikely to reverse trends in declining populations of seabirds, especially if conducted in isolation of other management actions, such as measures to enhance or expand the breeding habitat of seabirds. (90 ha) islands (see Figure 1) (Rand 1963a(Rand , 1963b. Whereas seal and seabird colonies co-existed on many of the islands three to four centuries ago, at the time when Europeans began to make their mark in the region (Shaughnessy 1984), the physical characteristics and faunal composition of many of the islands have altered radically since then. Between the 17th and the early 20th centuries, seals were hunted to extinction at many of the larger islands, including the aforementioned three and at least 20 other islands (Shaughnessy 1982). Many of these sites were subsequently manned on a year-round basis and managed for the production of seabird products such as guano and eggs, to the exclusion of seals. Hence, it became customary to refer to 'seal islands' and 'seabird islands' (or 'guano islands') exclusively. Seal islands included mainly small islands of 2 ha or less in area, which were inaccessible or