Fidaxomicin (Fdx) is a natural product antibiotic with potent activity against Clostridioides difficile and other Gram‐positive bacteria such as Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Only few Fdx derivatives have been synthesized and examined for their biological activity in the 50 years since its discovery. Fdx has a well‐studied mechanism of action, namely inhibition of the bacterial RNA polymerase. Yet, the targeted organisms harbor different target protein sequences, which poses a challenge for the rational development of new semisynthetic Fdx derivatives. We introduced substituents on the two phenolic hydroxy groups of Fdx and evaluated the resulting trends in antibiotic activity against M. tuberculosis, C. difficile, and the Gram‐negative model organism Caulobacter crescentus. As suggested by the target protein structures, we identified the preferable derivatisation site for each organism. The derivative ortho‐methyl Fdx also exhibited activity against the Gram‐negative C. crescentus wild type, a first for fidaxomicin antibiotics. These insights will guide the synthesis of next‐generation fidaxomicin antibiotics.