While the parent Ni 2 complex [Ni(RN Py S 4 )] 2 (1a, R ¼ H; RN Py S 4 ¼ 2,6-bis(2-mercaptophenylthiomethyl)-4-R-pyridine) cannot react with Fe(CO) 3 (BDA) in THF at room temperature, its substituted derivatives (1b, R ¼ MeO; 1c, Cl; 1d, Br; 1e, i-Pr; 1f, BzO; 1g, MeS) have been found to react with Fe(CO) 3 (BDA) under the same conditions to give the first [RN Py S 4 ] ligand-containing heterodinuclear [NiFe]-hydrogenase model complexes NiFe(RN Py S 4 )(CO) 3 (2b, R ¼ MeO; 2c, Cl; 2d, Br; 2e, i-Pr; 2f, BzO; 2g, MeS) along with the mononuclear [Fe]-hydrogenase model complexes Fe(RN Py S 4 )(CO) (3b, R ¼ MeO; 3c, Cl; 3d, Br; 3e, i-Pr;3f, BzO; 3g, MeS). However, when Ni 2 complexes 1a-1g react with Fe(CO) 3 (BDA) in THF at the higher temperature of 40 C, only the mononuclear complexes 3a-3g are obtained without the corresponding dinuclear complexes 2a-2g being isolated. While all the new complexes are characterized by elemental analysis and spectroscopy, the molecular structures of 1f, 2c, 3f and 3g have been further confirmed by X-ray crystallography. In addition, a possible pathway for the formation of 2a-2g and 3a-3g is suggested, which has been proved by monitoring the reaction course of dinuclear Ni 2 complex 1e with Fe(CO) 3 (BDA) using in situ IR spectroscopy.