The past two decades have brought a major evolution in our understanding of promoter structure, transcription factors, and mechanisms by which transcriptional initiation is regulated in eukaryotes. Multiple approaches have been used to establish current models for transcriptional regulation, including the development of in vitro transcription systems using either naked DNA or reconstituted chromatin, genetic analysis of gene regulation in yeast and Drosophila, and in vivo analysis of either endogenous cellular genes or transiently transfected, exogenous gene promoters. It is now clear that chromatin structure, once considered to be transparent to the process of transcription, plays an important role in the regulation of gene expression (reviewed in Ref. 1). Since all cellular genes are packaged into ordered chromatin structures, an understanding of the mechanisms by which nucleoprotein structure influences transcription activation is necessary for a complete paradigm of gene regulation in higher eukaryotes.Studies on regulation of endogenous mammalian genes are challenging due to the lack of genetic techniques available in yeast and Drosophila systems, which allow targeted insertion of promoters and gene disruption. Structural analysis of integrated gene promoters in mammalian cells requires the time-consuming generation of multiple stable cell lines or pools, in which the integrated genes would be subject to position effects from surrounding chromatin. Therefore, the identification and characterization of factors involved in mammalian gene expression have been addressed primarily through the use of transient transfection assays. In this approach, exogenous plasmid DNA, usually promoter/reporter constructs and transcription factor expression vectors, is introduced into cultured cells and expressed transiently, without replication or integration into the cellular genome. A variety of transfection methods has been utilized, including calcium phosphate precipitation (2), DEAE-dextran (3), electroporation (4, 5), and liposomemediated transfer (6). These studies have resulted in an abundance of information about promoter structure (i.e. identification of cisacting elements), transcription factor structure and function, and the characterization of transcription factor interactions that are part of various cellular regulatory pathways. However, in light of the accumulating evidence indicating a role for chromatin structure in transcription, it is appropriate to question whether transiently transfected gene promoters are adequate models for transcriptional regulatory mechanisms active on endogenous genes in ordered, replicated chromatin.
Structural Studies on Transiently Transfected DNAThe first issue to consider for transient templates is whether these molecules acquire physiologically spaced nucleosomes when introduced into cultured, mammalian cells. Since assembly of nucleosomes on endogenous genes is coupled to DNA replication, it is questionable whether transfected plasmids, which rarely carry mammalian replication...