We have examined DNA methylation in diploid human fibroblasts, early and late in their replicative life-span. The extent of methylation of -C-C-G-G-was measured by comparison of fragment sizes after digestion with methylation-specific restriction enzyme Hpa II or Msp I, or both. Methylation of -C-C-G-Gsites in total DNA, occurring predominantly at internal (3') cytosines, increased from 59% to 64% of sites in one cell strain at late passage, remained constant in another, and decreased in four other strains (54% to 48%, 58.5% to 48%, 55% to 51.5%, and 52% to 44.5%). Base composition analysis confirmed a substantial loss of total DNA 5-methylcytosine (mC) in one strain. Seven clonal isolates, examined at middle to late passage, ranged from 33% to 51% methylation of3' cytosines in -C-C-G-G-sites. Three discrete classes of highly repetitive DNA were found which contained Msp I sites at intervals of 45, 110, and 175 base pairs. These repeat families consistently had 70-80% of sites methylated at 3' cytosines, in all clones and in all strains examined both at early and at late passage. Thus, altered methylation of repetitive sequences is unlikely to account for the variable -C-C-G-G-methylation observed in total DNA. When DNA from one fibroblast strain and from eight pure clones isolated from that parental culture was digested with Msp I or Hpa H followed by EcoRI and probed for y-globin gene sequences, considerable interclonal and intraclonal heterogeneity was observed for methylation at four -C-C-G-Gsites in the y-globin codingregion ofDNA. Therefore, the pattern of methylation in endogenous gene regions appears to undergo random drift during replication of diploid fibroblasts.Cytosine methylation has been found to diminish at certain CpG sites in and around genes that have been expressed by a given tissue, relative to tissues that have never expressed those genes (1-7). It therefore has been proposed that differentiation involves a heritable loss of specific cytosine methylations, associated with-the initial expression ofnearby genes (3-5). Residual methylation at hypomethylated sites in expressing tissues has generally been attributed to nonexpressing cell types invariably present in whole tissues (1-5). However, the question of whether individual clonal isolates of a single diploid cell type also vary in methylation patterns has not been addressed.Recent studies of the heritability of site-specific DNA methylation have utilized exogenous transforming DNA molecules, either methylated in vitro or unmethylated (8,9). The results indicated only one instance of de novo methylation (8) and highly variable retention (15-70%) ofprior methylation over 25 cell generations (8,9). We now report that methylation of endogenous genes is also inherited unstably in clonal isolates of diploid human fibroblasts.
MATERIALS AND METHODSHuman Diploid Fibroblast Strains. Fibroblast strains were established as described (10-12) from forearm biopsy specimens from normal donors and were grown in Eagle's medium with 15% fetal calf ...