The superconducting magnet energy storage (SMES) has become an increasingly popular device with the development of renewable energy sources. The power fluctuations they produce in energy systems must be compensated with the help of storage devices. A toroidal SMES magnet with large capacity is a tendency for storage energy because it has great energy density and low stray field. A key component in the creation of these superconducting magnets is the material from which they are made. The present work describes a comparative numerical analysis with finite element method, of energy storage in a toroidal modular superconducting coil using two types of superconducting material with different properties bismuth strontium calcium copper oxide (BSCCO) and yttrium barium copper oxide (YBCO). Regarding the design of the modular torus, it was obtained that for a 1.25 times increase of the critical current for the BSCCO superconducting material compared with YBCO, the dimensions of the BSCCO torus were reduced by 7% considering the same stored energy. Also, following a numerical parametric analysis, it resulted that, in order to maximize the amount of energy stored, the thickness of the torus modules must be as small as possible, without exceeding the critical current. Another numerical analysis showed that the energy stored is maximum when the major radius of the torus is minimum, i.e., for a torus as compact as possible.