Nurse Migration in Australia, Germany, and the UK: A Rapid Evidence Assessment of Empirical Research Involving Migrant Nurses

Abstract

Forecasts predict a growing shortage of skilled nursing staff in countries worldwide. Nurse migration is already a common strategy used to address nursing workforce needs. Germany, the UK, and Australia are reviewed here as examples of destination countries for nurse migrants. Agreements exist between countries to facilitate nurse migration; however, it is not evident how nurse migrants have contributed to data on which these arrangements are based. We examined existing primary research on nurse migration, including educational needs and initiatives to support policymakers’, stakeholders’, and health professions educators’ decisions on measures for ethical and sustainable nurse migration. We conducted a rapid evidence assessment to review available empirical research data which involved, was developed with, or considered migrant nurses to address the research question: what are the findings of research that directly involves migrant nurses in producing primary research data? A total of 56 papers were included. Four main themes were identified in this research data: Research does not clearly define what is meant by the term migrant nurses; discrimination is often reported by migrant nurses; language and communication competencies are important; and structured integration programs are highly valued by migrant nurses and destination healthcare employers. Migrant nurses continue to experience discrimination and reduced career opportunities and therefore should be included in research about them to better inform policy. Structured integration programs can improve the experience of migrant nurses by providing language support (if necessary), a country-specific bridging program and help with organisational hurdles. Not only researching migrant nurses but making them active partners in research is of great importance for successful, ethical, and sustainable migration policies. A broader evidence base, especially with regard to the views and experiences of migrant nurses and their educational support needs, should be promoted to make future immigration policy more needs-based, sustainable and ethically acceptable.

Barriers and enabling factors for workplace integration of internationally qualified nurses: A qualitative study of perceptions of German nurses

“…In this study, nurses may not feel equal or equally supported by their authority. Although common goals may be given & Atkins, 2002;Smith et al, 2022;Wesołowska et al, 2020).…”

Promoting equitable health workforce distribution through improved migration governance: A mixed methods study of African health professionals' perceptions in Australia

“…Earlier studies have also noted concerns with the integration of SHW migrants and have recommended that they expand their social networks and acquire new language/cultural skills to ensure a smooth transition into the Australian system 56–60 . While this recommendation is essential, it provides little assistance to SHW migrants as they adjust to living in a destination country and navigate their role in strengthening health systems in both Australia and their home countries 61 .…”

An Intersectional Approach to Hepatitis B

“…Australia’s medical workforce is increasingly diverse, with international medical graduates disproportionately practising in regional areas [ 45 ]. The nursing workforce is similarly diverse, with India, China, and the Philippines remaining prominent sources of recruitment and settlement [ 46 ].…”

“…The Australian health system is heavily reliant on diasporic health professionals in the fields of nursing and medicine, as well as in support services such as catering, cleaning, and security. Added to the already gendered and hierarchical nature of health professions and the uneven power relations between the various professions, the element of diasporic cultural experience further increases the complexity of professional identity formation through educational discourses in healthcare settings [ 46 , 59 ].…”