Objective and Perceived Neighborhood Greenness of Students Differ in Their Agreement in Home and Study Environments

Abstract

Research has reported the associations between objective or subjective neighborhood greenness and health, with low agreement between the greenness scores. College students are prone to poor health, and data are lacking on home and university environments. We studied the agreement between greenness parameters and the associations of objective greenness with health in different locations. Three hundred and seventy-seven college students were recruited, with a mean age of 24 years, in the city of Graz, Austria. Objective and perceived greenness was assessed at home and at university. Health measures included the WHO-5 questionnaire for mental health, the IPAQ questionnaire (short) for physical activity and sedentariness, and body mass index. Per location, quintile pairs of objective and perceived greenness were classified into underestimates, correct estimates or overestimates. Interrater reliability and correlation analyses revealed agreement between greenness scores at home but not at university. ANOVA models only showed poorer mental health for students underestimating greenness at university (M = 51.38, SD = 2.84) compared to those with correct estimates (M = 61.03, SD = 1.85). Agreement between greenness scores at home but not at university was obtained, and mental health was related to the perception of greenness at university. We conclude that reliable and corresponding methods for greenness scores need to be developed.

Can Campus Green Spaces Be Restorative? A Case Study from Tanzania

“…Other studies focusing on university students found that perceived greenness, UGSs, or academic GSs help them reduce feelings of anxiety, depression, and uncertainty or, conversely, promote psychological rehabilitation and academic performance [34,72,87,[171][172][173][174][175][176][177][178][179][180][181][182]. This has become even more apparent following the COVID-19 pandemic lockdowns that were implemented on a global level.…”

Natural Environments in University Campuses and Students’ Well-Being

“…The main findings of all but one [19] of the studies pointed to a positive association between campus greenery and well-being of students, indicating the restorative role of greenness and water bodies on campus and/or around students' residential areas. One of the 32 studies, undertaken in a natural desert environment, found a protective role of brownness (35% decrease in the incidence of depression), which may be explained by scarce green areas and familiarity with the desert environment and color [29]. In 12 of the studies, authors focused on green spaces' settings and type of nature in association to mental wellbeing.…”

The Relationship between Perceptions and Objective Measures of Greenness

“…Perceptions of greenness can be fluid based on differences in the makeup of the natural environment. For example, some previous work that suggests the environment in which a study is conducted may lead to more discordance than the measures used to assess perceived and objective greenness [ 65 ]. The different relationships between the subjective and objective greenness scales that arose when using the same scales in different environments may be due to the variations in the types of greenness across different environments, suggesting the attributes of the greenness are important in perceptions but may not be captured in all objective measures.…”