“…In Stahl's (1697, p. 84) theory, heat is the motion of molecules, while phlogiston is a material principle; changes of state are not due to heat, and phlogiston is not heat. According to Stahl, there is 2 For example, Lavoisier possessed the 1757 French translation of Juncker's work as well as the 1730 original, Beretta (1995, p. 171), and the following Juncker quote appears to be the clear source for Lavoisier's (1774, p. 512) comment that Priestley's (1772) paper was a tissue of experiments hardly interrupted by any reasoning. 3 In the tradition of French books on chemistry, De Clave (1641) thought that fire was not an element but several phenomena and that air did not enter into compound bodies, so his five elements or principles were water, earth and mercury, sulphur and salt.…”