Obstruction results in quantization theory

Abstract

Quantization is not a straightforward proposition, as demonstrated by Groenewold's and Van Hove's discovery, more than fifty years ago, of an "obstruction" to quantization. Their "no-go theorems" assert that it is in principle impossible to consistently quantize every classical polynomial observable on the phase space R 2n in a physically meaningful way. Similar obstructions have been recently found for S 2 and T * S 1 , buttressing the common belief that no-go theorems should hold in some generality. Surprisingly, this is not so-it has just been proven that there are no obstructions to quantizing either T 2 or T * R+. In this paper we work towards delineating the circumstances under which such obstructions will appear, and understanding the mechanisms which produce them. Our objectives are to conjecture-and in some cases prove-generalized Groenewold-Van Hove theorems, and to determine the maximal Lie subalgebras of observables which can be consistently quantized. This requires a study of the structure of Poisson algebras of symplectic manifolds and their representations. To these ends we include an exposition of both prequantization (in an extended sense) and quantization theory, here formulated in terms of "basic algebras of observables." We then review in detail the known results for R 2n , S 2 , T * S 1 , T 2 , and T * R+, as well as recent theoretical work. Our discussion is independent of any particular method of quantization; we concentrate on the structural aspects of quantization theory which are common to all Hilbert spacebased quantization techniques.

Quantization Methods: A Guide for Physicists and Analysts

“…Also we gave up the von Neumann rule (q3), but it turns out that this is usually recovered to some extent, cf. [115].…”

On quantization of polynomial momentum observables

“…Relations of such type appears in various quantization approaches (see e.g. [3,19]). The simplest general form of von Neumann rule is…”

“…In the paper, the problem of quantization of polynomial classical observables is studied. It is well-known that it is impossible to fully quantize the algebra of polynomials on a Euclidean phase space [1,2,3]. Consequently, research has concentrated in two main directions.…”

The Operator Formulation of Classical Mechanics and Semiclassical Limit

“…Having one and the same algebraic product and one and the same Lie bracket for both mechanics, we shall be able to propose, we believe, unambiguous-obstruction free, quantization prescription. (The ordering rule and obstructions to quantization were previously discussed in [12][13][14][15][16][17].) Moreover, the dynamical equations of both classical and quantum mechanics will appear to be one and the same-the operator version of the Liouville equation.…”