Occupancy dynamics in human‐modified landscapes in a tropical island: implications for conservation design

Abstract

AimAvian communities in human-modified landscapes exhibit varying patterns of local colonization and extinction rates, determinants of species occurrence. Our objective was to model these processes to identify habitat features that might enable movements and account for occupancy patterns in habitat matrices between the Guanica and Susua forest reserves. This knowledge is central to conservation design, particularly in ever changing insular landscapes. LocationSouth-western Puerto Rico. MethodsWe used a multiseason occupancy modelling approach to quantify seasonal estimates of occupancy, and colonization and extinction rates of seven resident avian species surveyed over five seasons from January 2010 to June 2011. We modelled parameters by matrix type, expressions of survey station isolation, quality, amount of forest cover and context (embedded in forest patch). ResultsSeasonal occupancy remained stable throughout the study for all species, consistent with seasonally constant colonization and extinction probabilities. Occupancy was mediated by matrix type, higher in reserves and forested matrix than in the urban and agricultural matrices. This pattern is in accord with the forest affinities of all but an open-habitat specialist. Puerto Rican Spindalis (Spindalis portoricensis) exhibited high occupancy in the urban matrix, highlighting the adaptability of some insular species to novel environments. Highest colonization rates occurred when perching structures were at ≤ 500 m. Survey stations with at least three fruiting tree species and 61% forest cover exhibited lowest seasonal extinction rates. Main conclusionsOur work identified habitat features that influenced seasonal probabilities of colonization and extinction in a human-modified landscape. Conservation design decisions are better informed with increased knowledge about interpatch distances to improve matrix permeability, and habitat features that increase persistence or continued use of habitat stepping stones. A focus on dynamic processes is valuable because conservation actions directly influence colonization and extinction rates, and thus, a quantitative means to gauge their benefit. Disciplines ABSTRACTAim Avian communities in human-modified landscapes exhibit varying patterns of local colonization and extinction rates, determinants of species occurrence. Our objective was to model these processes to identify habitat features that might enable movements and account for occupancy patterns in habitat matrices between the Guanica and Susua forest reserves. This knowledge is central to conservation design, particularly in ever changing insular landscapes.Location South-western Puerto Rico.Methods We used a multiseason occupancy modelling approach to quantify seasonal estimates of occupancy, and colonization and extinction rates of seven resident avian species surveyed over five seasons from January 2010 to June 2011. We modelled parameters by matrix type, expressions of survey station isolation, quality, amount of forest cover and context (embed...

Producing Diversity: Agroforests Sustain Avian Richness and Abundance in India's Western Ghats

“…This sets the background for further analyses of bird-habitat relationships at multiple spatial scales, particularly of species that are of ecological and conservation importance. Opportunities for future research include comparisons of multiple land uses with protected reserves, as well as examining spatial dynamics (such as local extinction, colonization, turnover and change in occupancy) over time (Janowski et al, 2012;Irizarry et al, 2016). This requires establishing long-term monitoring studies of bird communities in the region.…”

Declining human population but increasing residential development around protected areas in Puerto Rico

“…Furthermore, there is a need to bring together diverse sources of data that reflect habitat and species dynamics to better understand residential effects on species persistence, extinction rates and distribution (Araújo and Williams, 2000;Araújo et al, 2008;Yackulic et al, 2015), to more effectively aide conservation design. This kind of work has been conducted for avian communities in lands surrounding state forests in Puerto Rico (Irizarry et al, 2016). Finally, it is equally important to understand how residential development alters ecosystem services provided by protected areas in tropical islands such as water supply, and climate regulation as well as whether these effects are increased or attenuated when housing units are vacant or occupied, a common scenario in regions with declining human population and expanding housing development.…”

Birds of the Land of Swallows: contribution of the main ecosystems of Cozumel Island to its avian diversity

“…Yet, some insular bird species have been shown to be able to overcome hazards and use human-disturbed habitats and related resources. In particular, synanthropic species have been shown to increase their abundances in highly disturbed areas, with an important number of species concentrating at intermediate-disturbance levels and in edge systems (Lugo et al 2012;Irizarry et al 2016;Titoko et al 2019). Furthermore, native vegetation on islands (e.g., mangroves and forests) do not only harbor important avian diversity but are often large-scale sources of diversity, mitigating some of the effects of human activities (Khimoun et al 2017;Wang et al 2017;Titoko et al 2019).…”