Of Bulls and Bulbs: Aspirations and Perceptions of Rural Youth in Zambia

Abstract

During the last years, policymakers and development-practitioners focused heavily on making farming more attractive for the rural youth in Africa. To reach this goal, different actions are proposed, often emphasizing the need for modern farming and information and communication technologies. These proposed actions are mostly based on anecdotes and prior policy beliefs, but not on empirical evidence since scientists have largely neglected this topic. This paper aims to contribute to a deeper understanding of the aspirations and perceptions of young people and therefore to the formulation of policy actions that fit these aspirations. Two research methods were used to explore the aspirations and perceptions of rural youth: interviews and drawing exercises, a novel method in this context that allows for both a qualification and quantification of aspirations. The results show that rural youth have very diverse opinions and aspirations. In contrast to the literature, young people were found to reflect carefully about the positive and negative sides of farming, rural and urban life, and of foreign countries. Imagining their future farm, young people mostly envisioned using draught animals and having electricity (which explaining the reference to bulls and bulbs in the title of this paper). In addition, the young people aspired to greater farm diversity and applying more fertilizer. Few respondents mentioned the use of modern technologies such as tractors, and none mentioned ICTs. While it is difficult to generalize our results, the findings suggest that policymakers and developmentpractitioners need to pay more attention to the actual aspirations of the rural youth to avoid wellintended but misguided policies.

Young people’s willingness to farm under present and improved conditions in Thailand

“…Studies have used the first approach to explore rural youth's intentions to get involved in farming in Africa (Daum, 2018;Yeboah et al, 2017). Bezu and Holden (2014) and Gella (2013) showed that young women often preferred to look for urban employment compared to their male counterparts, because farming was seen as a male occupation and because inheriting family land proved more difficult for women.…”

Gender differences in rice value chain participation and career preferences of rural youth in India

“…Hedge and Venkattakumar (2015) point out that, to revitalise Indian agriculture, there is a need to bring in profitability through better livelihood options and promoting entrepreneurship, which eventually attract the next generation. Daum (2018) argues that proposed policy briefs on the aspirations and perceptions of young people about farming are not based on empirical evidence. Daum suggests that policymakers and development practitioners pay more attention on the actual aspirations of rural youth to avoid well-intended but misguided policies.…”